Welcome to The Pie
At "The Pie," we celebrate the art of pizza crafting with a passion for quality and flavor. Nestled in the heart of Port Jefferson, our restaurant offers a casual dining experience complete with an inviting atmosphere and a diverse menu. From our delicious sampler platter to the delectable coal-fired pizzas, every dish reflects our commitment to fresh ingredients and innovative recipes. Vegetarian options abound, ensuring everyone can savor a slice of happiness. With outdoor seating, catering services, and delightful happy hour specials, "The Pie" is not just a meal; it’s a community hub where friends and families can gather and enjoy great food together.
-
216 Main St Port Jefferson, NY 11777 United States Hotline: (631) 331-4646
Welcome to The Pie, your next favorite destination for exquisite pizza in Port Jefferson, NY. Nestled at 216 Main St, this charming eatery is more than just a pizza joint; it's a culinary haven that caters to a wide range of palates. With a casual vibe and a commitment to quality, The Pie is the ideal spot for both families and friends looking to indulge in delicious dishes.
What sets The Pie apart is its emphasis on customer experience. From the moment you step inside, you're greeted with a warm ambiance complemented by moderate noise levels, making it perfect for lively gatherings or intimate dinners. Whether you're opting for a delightful indoor meal or enjoying the outdoors, the restaurant provides ample seating, including wheelchair accessibility and bike parking.
- Diverse Menu: The Pie takes pride in its variety of offerings. Start your meal with their Great Beginnings, featuring highlights like the Sampler Platter showcasing mouthwatering mozzarella sticks, fried ravioli, and delectable zucchini fritters. Each appetizer is perfectly crafted to excite your taste buds and set the stage for what’s to come.
- Salads and Soups: Comprehensive meal? Don’t skip the salads! Options like the Caramelized Pear Salad and Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato Plate showcase fresh ingredients and bold flavors. If you're in need of comfort, the homemade soups, such as the Stracciatella or Tomato Blue Cheese, are satisfying starters that warm the soul.
- Pizza Perfection: Of course, the star of the show is the pizza. With many vegetarian options available, there's something for everyone. Their coal-fired crusts are the perfect balance of crispiness and flavor, making each slice an unforgettable experience.
The Pie doesn’t only serve food; it offers an experience. Here, diners can take advantage of convenient utilities including free Wi-Fi, delivery, and takeout services. They accept credit cards, Apple Pay, and even cryptocurrency, ensuring a hassle-free visit.
As you gather around the table, sharing plates of delicious fare, take a moment to soak in the atmosphere. With features like outdoor seating, happy hour specials, and TV for sports fans, every visit feels like a celebration. The Pie truly understands the importance of great food and community.
Don’t miss out on the chance to savor exquisite flavors at The Pie. Plan your next lunch or dinner with them and discover why this pizza haven is quickly becoming a beloved staple in the neighborhood. For reservations, give them a call at (631) 331-4646.
Popped in after picking up our grandson from the ferry. What a great decision. Kerry our waitress was amazing. Attentive, friendly and totally checked in on us throughout our meal. Pizza and salads were great. Can't wait to come back.
Nice early dinner cozy spot to eat! Fast service. Our waitress has such great energy and positive vibes it made the experience even better. Started to fill up once we started to leave around 6pm. They host large parties too. I was craving coal fired pizza and that is what i got! Medium sized personal pie enough for two and a house salad also enough for two.
Went with my girlfriend and another couple and had an amazing experience. The restaurant is beautifully decorated and the service was outstanding. We split a Margarita pizza and it was delicious, the sauce was my favorite part. We also had a chicken bacon ranch pizza (secret menu item) which was absolutely exquisite. The other couple got the chicken Marsala which they said was amazing. We got garlic knots as well which were okay, lacking in any garlic flavor. For lunch this was a perfect spot, would definitely come back.
I've gone to The Pie many times with kids so have always had the pizza which is spectacular! This time however it was a kid free so we ventured to the food menu. Calamari to start I recommend the garlic dip! I had fettuccine Alfredo & added shrimp. My wife had the gnocchi, both excellent. I would recommend any of their desserts. Will visit again. If you go ask for Kerri as your waitress, she is hands down the best waitress I've ever dealt with
Good fresh pizza. Fresh ingredients. Salads are great too. This has been go to pizze place outside from Ginos in lake R. Will miss coming here !
The Pie is my favorite pizza place for thin crust pizza. My mom and I shared the mozzarella sticks to start which seemed deliciously homemade and are very stretchy. I got a classic margarita pie for my entree and my mom got a focaccia flatbread piled high with their house salad. We both enjoyed our meals and the service. We finished it off with a cookie dough blast, which is a chocolate chip cookie lava cake warm with vanilla ice cream.
Super yummy and fast service! Reasonably priced especially for an individual margarita pie. I've never dined in, but when I've gone inside to pick up my order it seems like a cozy and family friendly dining spot. The pizza definitely has a bit of garlic (which I happen to love but you might want a piece of gum/mint afterward), a great sauce and the perfect amount of cheese. Yum! I need to try some more items off the menu at The Pie.
Came here with my in-laws and my fiancé sister for lunch and wasn't surprised at all on the quality of food coming out this restaurant. Located in the heart of port Jefferson and along the strip where you'll find plenty of great food spots/ bars for brunch, lunch, or dinner. Came here because this is great place my in-laws visit and eat a lot at. The staff here was very welcoming and I see why my in-laws love this place. Our waitress was very sweet and helpful with food options and I wish I remembered her name, but was amazing all around. She offered great options on food and gluten free options. We ordered 3 brick oven pies and every pie was great. I'm a Brick oven pizza whore and can eat brick over pizza every day. This an old review and I wish I wrote it sooner, so I could detail exactly everything we had. We ordered a margarita pie, chick pesto with bacon, and a sausage pie. Every pie was great, but my favorite was the chicken pesto with bacon. My fiancé sister got chicken fingers with French fries and the chicken fingers here are 10/10. I would never order chicken fingers in a pizza/restaurant, but they were 1 of the best I had. Came here in the summer and what I love about port Jefferson is you can make a great day out of it. Easily convenient to the ferry where you can go from port Jefferson in your car to Connecticut or keep it local. There is plenty of bars, restaurants, site seeing, shopping, etc. Great restaurant with amazing food and brick oven pizza. This place offer amazing pasta and Italian entrees other than pizza. Highly recommend if you're looking for great food !