The Pie Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to The Pie, where pizza transcends the ordinary! Nestled at 216 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY, this casual dining spot brings a variety of mouth-watering dishes to the table, perfect for family outings or casual get-togethers. The menu begins with delightful appetizers like the Sampler Platter featuring mozzarella sticks and fried ravioli, ideal for sharing. Vegetarians will appreciate the extensive selection, including salads like the Gorgonzola Mixed Greens and a variety of homemade soups. For the main event, their pizza offerings promise a burst of flavor with every bite. Don't miss the California-style toppings, which showcase local produce. Pair your meal with a selection from their beer and wine menu for a complete experience. With options for outdoor seating and catering services, The Pie is the perfect spot for every occasion. Make a reservation today or opt for takeout to enjoy at home!
Great Beginnings
Sampler Platter
mozzarella sticks, fried ravioli, fried zucchini
Mozzarella Sticks
Fried Ravioli
marinara dipping sauce
Zucchini Fritte
crisp zucchini served with marinara and garlic aioli
Buffalo Wings
Coal Fired Garlic Bread
Garlic Knots
House Meatballs
topped with ricotta and mozzarella
Calamari Fritti
Mozzarella en Carrozza
fresh mozzarella lightly breaded
Baked Clams
Clams Oreganato
littleneck clams, garlic, basil, toasted oreganato, and bread crumbs
Bruschetta di Pomodoro
plum tomato, red onion, basil, fresh mozzarella with garlic crostini
Mussels
Red or white sauce
Fried Articholes
House Salad
tomato, cucumber, red onion, carrots, croutons, mushrooms, candied walnuts, red wine vinaigrette
Classic Caesar
Fresh Mozzarella & Tomato Plate
Flat Bread Focaccia
seasoned coal fired crust topped with our house salad
Gorgonzola
mixed greens, red onion, cucumber, roasted pepper, candied walnuts, crumbled gorgonzola, balsamic vinaigrette
Grilled Vegetable
portobello mushrooms, zucchini, eggplant, roasted red peppers, over mixed greens with balsamic reduction
Caramelized Pear Salad
pears, tomatoes, red onion, candied walnuts, gorgonzola cheese over mixed greens with raspberry vinaigrette
Salads
Soups
Tomato Blue Cheese
Tortellini en Brodo
Homemade Stracciatella
Soup of the Day
Chicken
Meatball
Eggplant
Grilled Chicken
Sausage & Peppers
Shrimp
Parmigiana
Main Plates
Eggplant Rollatini
ricotta, marinara, melted mozzarella
Chicken Francese
lemon, butter, white wine sauce
Chicken Marsala
fresh mushrooms, brown marsala sauce
Chicken Scarpariello
sweet sausage, potatoes, cherry peppers, mushrooms
Chicken Sorrentino
eggplant, prosciutto, mushroom, melted mozzarella
The Original
seasoned ricotta, mozzarella and pecorino romano
Broccoli Rabe & Spicy Sausage
ricotta, mozzarella, broccoli rabe and hot italian sausage and pècorino romano
Meat Calzone
meat sauce, ricotta, fresh mozzarella and pecorino romano
Vegetable Calzone
portobello mushrooms, eggplant, spinach, ricotta, fresh mozzarella and pecorino romano
Coal Fired Calzones
Pasta
Penne Vodka
Gnocchi Bolognese
meat sauce topped with ricotta
Spaghetti & Meatballs
Chicken & Broccoli
chicken, broccoli, garlic and oil, fresh tomato, rigatoni pasta
Capellini Primavera
asparagus, shiitake mushrooms, sundried tomato, fresh zucchini, fresh garlic and oil
Linguini with Clam Sauce
red or white
Rigatoni Rustica
Italian sausage, broccoli rabe, garlic and oil
Shrimp Cappellini
arugula, tomatoes, roasted garlic, white wine
Ravioli
cheese ravioli with tomato sauce
Baked Ziti
Lasagna with Meat
Broccoli Rabe
Escarole & Beans
Broccoli
Spinach
Meatballs
Sides
Dessert
Brownie Sundae
Ghirardelli chocolate brownie served with vanilla bean ice cream and whipped cream
Cookie Dough Blast
warm chocolate chip cookie with chocolate filling served with vanilla bean ice cream
Funnel Sticks
sweet fried dough dusted with confectioners' sugar served with caramel dipping sauce
Tartufo
vanilla and chocolate ice cream with raspberry and nut center dipped in a dark chocolate shell
Sweetie Pie Sundae
warm sweet dough topped with vanilla bean ice cream, caramel, chocolate syrup and whipped cream (serves 2 or more)
Nutella S'mores Pie
warm sweet dough topped with roasted marshmallow, banana and graham crackers (serves 2 or more)
Mini Cannoli (3)
NY Cheesecake
Tiramisu
Coke
Free Refills
Diet Coke
Free Refills
Sprite
Free Refills
Dr. Pepper
Free Refills
Root Beer
Free Refills
Iced Tea
Free Refills
Hi-C
Free Refills
Lemonade
Free Refills
Fountain Soft Drinks
Boylan Bottling Co.
Crème
Black Cherry
Orange
Ginger Ale
Acqua Panna
Pellegrino
Bottled Water
By the Bottle
Budweiser
Bud Light
Corona
Heineken
Heineken Light
Peroni
Stella Artois
Brooklyn Lager
Brooklyn Seasonal
On Tap
Coal Fired Pizza
Classic Margherita
crisp crust, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, basil, pecorino Romano, olive oil
Di Parma
sliced Parma prosciutto, Kalamata olives, artichoke hearts, fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce
Blanco
ricotta, fresh mozzarella, olive oil, fresh basil and Romano
Rustica
broccoli rabe, sausage, fresh mozzarella, roasted red peppers, garlic, parmigiana, olive oil (with or without tomato sauce)
Shrimp or Clam
fresh shrimp or littleneck clams prepared with fresh garlic, white wine, fresh mozzarella and toasted bread crumb oreganato
Verde
chicken, pesto, ricotta and fresh mozzarella
Barbecue style
chicken, BBQ sauce, fresh mozzarella cheese, caramelized onion
Melanzana
eggplant, roasted red peppers, mushrooms, tomato sauce and fresh mozzarella
Supreme
sausage, pepperoni, meatballs. peppers, onions, black olives, fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce
Vegetable
asparagus, portabella mushrooms, eggplant, Kalamata olives, tomato sauce, fresh mozzarella, olive oil and shaved parmigiana
Baby Bella
wild mushrooms, spinach, truffle oi, ricotta and fresh mozzarella
Buffalo
spicy chicken, blue cheese, fresh mozzarella mild, medium, hot and fire